When the original film adaptations of Suzanne Collins’s Hunger Games books were announced, a lot of the excitement was tempered by the question of “but how are they going to do *that* in 12a-rated movies?!” It was a question answered in emphatic style across a quadrilogy of four of the best blockbusters of their era, but you might wonder if Collins, knowing now that she’s writing for the screen as much as the page, would tame her prequels to make it easier on the studio. Thankfully, she really hasn’t, with second prequel Sunrise on the Reaping still brutal. Like 2023’s Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, it’s not a patch on the original four, and there’s a vast, Jennifer Lawrence-shaped absence where a compelling lead performance should be, but the admirable commitment to bleakness still carries this to the finish line.

After Ballad… took us 64 years back to the early days of the Games and pre-presidency Coriolanus Snow, Sunrise… concerns itself with the more recent past of Panem, 24 years before Katniss’s victory-turned-revolution. We follow the man who will one day become Katniss’s Woody Harrelson-played mentor, Haymitch Abernathy (played here by Joseph Zada), during the 50th edition of the Games, an anniversary celebrated by doubling the amount of ‘Tributes’, the evil Capitol sending 48 kids to kill each other in an arena instead of the usual 24.

Obviously, there are a lot of foregone conclusions at play. We know going in that Haymitch will win, which means we also know that all the other kids we meet are going to die, and long-time franchise director Francis Lawrence and writers Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie do struggle to turn that inevitability into tension. That’s not to say there’s no heart-in-mouth stuff at all – individual set pieces still have the same grim, panicked horror that have always defined this series’ action – but you never *worry* about Haymitch in the way you used to with Katniss.

In place of surprise comes a lot more lore, both about Haymitch himself and the (at points absurd) compounding tragedies that turned him into the cynical drunk of the original series and about a lot of other familiar Hunger Games names. Most of the adults in Sunrise… are the ones we already know the older selves of, and this ends up mostly serving as an origin story for the revolutionary conspiracy that Katniss will become crucial to come Catching Fire in the originals. It’s certainly not as exciting as the revolution itself, but the groundwork is laid interestingly enough to keep you engaged, even if this is absolutely *not* a jumping on point for the series; you do really need to have seen all five of the previous films to feel comfortable here.

It’s very interesting to see how the younger-adult actors each interpret their task differently. As future Philip Seymour Hoffman and Elizabeth Banks, Jesse Plemons and Elle Fanning are basically pitch-perfect as quiet Capitol dissident Plutarch Heavensbee and earnest fashionista Effie Trinket respectively. Then you’ve got Kieran Culkin as the will-be Stanley Tucci TV announcer Caesar Flickerman, not really doing much to differentiate Caesar from Roman Roy, and, at the other extreme, Kelvin Harrison Jr doing a hilariously strained Jeffrey Wright impersonation as tech whiz victor Beetee.

The big question is, though, can Ralph Fiennes match up to Donald Sutherland as President Snow, and the answer is…he’s not in this enough to fully tell, but I think not quite, lacking Sutherland’s sedately venomous aura. Meanwhile, on the Tributes front, Zada is, bluntly, no Jennifer Lawrence, giving a functional but not particularly charismatic lead performance. Haymitch goes through a lot of traumas, but Zada can’t muster up a moment to match, say, Lawrence’s devastating moment of overwhelming grief and terror after the death of Rue in the original.

To be fair, Lawrence really was lightning in a bottle for the originals, and recapturing that would be a minor miracle, and Sunrise… does manage to carve its own identity in its visual sensibilities. Where Katniss’s arena was mostly just a forest, Haymitch’s is a technicolour paradise garden, the Capitol in full show-off mode with fields of brightly coloured flowers that emit flammable gas, butterflies that put the ‘electric’ in ‘electric blue’, poison rivers, and a full volcano. It’s the series at its most spectacularly sci-fi, often eye-popping and particularly welcome after the almost entirely downbeat Ballad…

Surprisingly enough for a prequel, there’s a real sense of finality to Sunrise on the Reaping both on-screen (an ending coda does really feel like farewell) and off (Francis Lawrence is preparing to enter a long engagement with a new YA franchise in the form of Red Rising). It’s not anywhere near as strong a goodbye as just leaving things off with Mockingjay 2 would have been, but I still, overall, found myself happy with the opportunity to take one last peek at the nightmare world of Panem.

3/5

Directed by Francis Lawrence

Written by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie

Starring; Joseph Zada, Jesse Plemons, Ralph Fiennes

Runtime: 158 mins

Rating: 12